Red Velvet Black and White Cookies

IMG_0834

Eating a black and white cookie is a science. Or an art.  Or one of those things that requires technique and skill and maybe even a bachelor’s degree in cookie eating.

Man, I wish I had one of those.

IMG_0838

Some people eat them haphazardly, not really noticing whether they’re eating the vanilla or the chocolate side.  Sometimes getting a little of both at once.

I don’t know how you guys feel about this. But to me.  That just seems wrong.

See, here’s what I do.  First, I eat the chocolate side.  Because I like it less.  Don’t get me wrong.  It’s chocolate-y and beautiful and if you’re more of a chocolate person than a vanilla person, you probably want to do the opposite because, really, it’s glorious.  But I am who I am.

And who I am is a girl who really loves her vanilla glaze.

So then when I have eaten every last bit of chocolate, even nibbling up to the line in the middle while still doing my best not to cross any vanilla-filled boundaries,.  (Yeah, I have issues.  Apparently black-and-white cookies bring them out in me.  I’m sure my mother has something to do with this.)

I can sit back, relax, and enjoy.  Life. Is. Good.

(Now I know you’re looking at that bitten cookie up there, with that bite that includes both vanilla and chocolate. And thinking.  Sacrilege!  Heresy!  Off with her head! And well.  Look, there are just some things that we, as food bloggers, need to do for aesthetic and political reasons.  You can rest assured that I never let it happen again and that all of the cookies I ate afterward were ingested using the true and proper method described above.  Amen.)

IMG_0821

With all of this red velvet in the mix, you may be thinking that these are a week late and a dollar short.

Well, I am here to alert you that this is not true.  Especially not here in NYC where, not only does no one ever sleep, but we also never tire of eating black and white cookies (and we were also kind of a little scared that Amy would disown us if we posted anything red and cutesy on V-Day).  They are staples, my friend.  Staples.

Some of you may never have had them before.  Some of you may have only had those little mini versions from Costco.  (And you’re calling me the heretic?  Sheesh.)  Those do not hold a candle to the real deal.  So just, you know.  Don’t judge a cookie by it’s Costco counterpart.

Deal?

IMG_0837

Red Velvet Black and White Cookies
 
This classic New York cookie gets a fun red velvet twist in these Red Velvet Black and White Cookies!
Yield: 12 cookies
Ingredients
For the cookies
  • 1¼ cup AP flour
  • 1 tbsp cocoa powder
  • ½ tsp salt
  • ½ tsp baking soda
  • 5 tbsp butter, room temperature
  • ¾ cup sugar
  • 1 egg
  • 1 tsp vanilla
  • ½ cup buttermilk
  • a pinch of red food gel coloring
For the vanilla glaze
  • 2 cups powdered sugar
  • 1 tbsp light corn syrup
  • ½ tsp vanilla extract
  • 1-2 tbsp hot water
For the chocolate glaze
  • 4 oz semi-sweet chocolate (use Hershey’s. I used really good chocolate and it just tasted too good, if you know what I mean)
  • 3 tbsp butter
  • 1 tbsp light corn syrup
Instructions
  1. Preheat oven to 350. Line two baking sheets with parchment paper or grease and flour them REALLY WELL so that the cookies don’t stick. These are super cake-y so they will stick. Every chance they get. Be wary.
  2. In a medium bowl, sift together flour, cocoa powder, salt and baking soda.
  3. Using a mixer, cream 5 tbsp butter with the sugar until fluffy, about 3 minutes. Beat in the egg and vanilla. Beat in the flour mixture alternating with the buttermilk until smooth. Dip the back of a spoon into your red food gel and then dip it into your batter. Mix until evenly distributed. Add more until you get the red color that you desire.
  4. Place ¼ cup scoops of batter about 2 inches apart on the prepared baking sheet. Using a butter knife, spread the batter so that they are still quite thick but are flat on top. THIS IS CRUCIAL. If these are too thin, they will fall apart when you are trying to put icing on them. Because they are cake-y they are ONLY sturdy if they are thick and they will spread quite a bit, I promise. So just be careful. Bake until a toothpick inserted comes out dry, about 12-15 minutes. Let sit for 5 minutes and then transfer to a cooling rack.
  5. For the vanilla glaze, whisk together the powdered sugar, vanilla, corn syrup, and hot water until smooth. When the cookies are cool, face them bottom side up and spread half of the cookie with vanilla glaze. You can do this with a butter knife.
  6. For the chocolate glaze, in a bowl, melt the butter and chocolate in the microwave for about 1 minute or until melted. Add the corn syrup and stir until smooth.
  7. Spread this over the second half of the cookies (use a spoon). Refrigerate/freeze for 20 minutes to set.
Notes
Adapted from Rachael Ray
Nutrition Information
Serving size: 1 cookie

IMG_0827

You are reading this post on Eats Well With Others at https://joanne-eatswellwithothers.com. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to the author and or owner of Eats Well With Others. All rights reserved by Joanne Bruno.

Similar Posts

114 Comments

  1. Just submitted this winner to StumbleUpon……dang these look good. You are sooo right, something about folks from NYC and these cookies. I am with you, there has gotta be a method to my eating this kind of thing. The 1st one I am careful on & then any additional I am a slamming fool 🙂 xxoo

  2. I’ve never even heard of a black and white cookie, much less tried one. However, I would glaze them in stripes in order to get a little of both icings at once. Now everyone in NYC will be scratching their heads and saying “why didn’t I think of that?”!! They do look delicious!

    Best,
    Bonnie

  3. My gut reaction says that I would eat the white side first to get the yummy part right away…..BUT…I think I would have a hard time not jamming it all straight into my mouth right away. These look so good!

  4. These look totally yum! We call them half moons in Mass, and they are one of my favorites. I do the same thing, eating one side at a time, savoring each for its different flavors. I love the idea to make it with red velvet; that sounds great:) I finally figured out how to bookmark; so I am doing that right now..lol

  5. Joanne – Paul here (Amy’s hubby, guinea pig, and foil in acting),

    So every morning I coming into the office, and she has your blog up and I see these pictures of awesomeness. But today, this one just GOT me. So I’m going to plead upon my beautiful better half to make these little discs of heaven.

    Great writing, BTW.

  6. LOL. Truth be told, I probably wouldn’t have been that upset had you posted these on Monday…I mean, look at them! Who could stay mad?

    And I see I have a request from my comic relief and chief bottle washer (above) to make a batch. So away I go. I have all the ingredients (naturally), so therefore I have no excuse.

  7. OMG too funny! I have similar issues when it comes to eating! I ALWAYS save the best bites for LAST! What stands out in my mind (the dish I do it most with) is sushi – always saving the best piece for my final bite! Cookies, cake…sandwiches too!

    These cookies are a site to behold!

  8. Ahhhh! I almost made these for a V-day treat but decided to eat dark chocolate caramels instead (my roommate is sabatoging my diet). Now I want cookies. And I too prefer the vanilla glaze over the chocolate.

  9. Red Velvet under the B&W? Now thats smart!! We don’t get black and White cookies here, yup, even in Costco. I will admit, I have never been the biggest fan of Rachel Ray, but this…this could be the start of a lot of good things….

  10. My kids would be thanking you for making these brilliant cookies! I have been told time and again how red velvet is their favorite, but the thought of making a cake with 2 pounds of sugar has stopped me in the past: perfect alternative!

  11. My knowledge of the black and white cookie comes from Seinfeld and that’s the extent of it. However, I do know (and love) red velvet!

    BTW, I’d save the chocolate for last…I’m one of those people!

  12. Love the idea of adding red velvet to the black and white mix…and I love your method of eating them! It’s been far too long since I had a proper black and white cookie…I either need to head to NYC or get in the kitchen and make these! 😉

  13. im sorry, did you say Rachael ray? as in the lady who doesnt bake??? im amazed! those are beauts! jees
    I think you and i can have a B&W cookie party. You can eat all my vanilla and i will eat all your chocolate. My thing is that the vanilla side is a different texture and waaay sweeter than the chocolate side. I love to literally break it in half and go nuts. and i do nibble the ends to make sure no colors have crossed over. im a racist that way.

  14. I miss seeing black and whites in bakeries after growing up on the east coast. I may need to make these for a little reminder. I have never had success with a red velvet cookie so, I am intrigued on many levels. Love you eating technique … so me and now so my children … ugg the nuts behavior I am passing along!

  15. Oh man, growing up I ate a black and white cookie from a local bakery almost every single day. Apparently Mayor Bloomberg eats one a day also. I’m totally with you, the vanilla part reigns supreme. How creative to use a red velvet base!

  16. I hope you didn’t just make that story up, because I’m about to admit that I eat cookies like this the same way, one side, and then the other, saving the best for last (yes, always vanilla over chocolate). I even eat chocolate chip cookies around what I think is the best part of the cookied (doughy center with two nice big chips)!

  17. OMG, it’s been ages since I’ve tasted a good B&W cookie. I don’t trust the packaged stuff to compare with the memories. (I eat the vanilla hemisphere first.)

    But with a red velvet cake base, wow — these are B&W cookies to the nth power. Absolutely fantastic!!! Thanks, Joanne!

  18. Most of the time I skip right over black and white cookie recipes, because truthfully, most people have no idea what they’re supposed to taste like. And my mom and I decided that NYC chocolate tastes different than what you get anywhere else. But I feel like you actually know what you’re talking about!

    PS: I like to take a bite from each side first to see which is yummier, then I eat the least yummy side first.

  19. This cookie was a part of our lives until retirement. Apparently bakers who made them didn’t make it over the Rocky Mountains. I haven’t seen them here. It is good to have a recipe so I can make my own. Have a great day. Blessings…Mary

  20. Sadly, I hate Rachael Ray (even when I met her, I tried not to stare directly into her eyes for fear of being turned to stone), but I forgive you because you are awesome, and these cookies do look pretty darn tasty. Much love, your un-judgmental friend, Victoria 🙂

  21. I have never had a true black and white cookie… I need to remedy that next time I am in NYC. In the meantime, they have been on my list to make for a long time… I should really get to it already! I’d probably eat the vanilla side first.

  22. Vanilla and chocolate and red velvet cake….
    oh my! The first one, I would eat the vanilla first…and then eat the chocolate….the next one, would be chocolate…and then vanilla. I’m terrible at making decisions. Have a great weekend! Candace

  23. Every time I read your blog I feel guilty for only eating desserts as indulgent as you share, but being too lazy to actually attempt to make them myself. I need schooling. These are drool-worthy. And I like that you appreciate the find art of cookie consumption. It’s a good sign of character, I think.

  24. I’ve lived right outside of NYC my entire life (and worked in the city for over 10 years) and although I know the B&W cookie is “famous” here, it was never that big of a deal! We were always way more into Italian pastries. Still, the fresh ones are WAY better than Costco 🙂 I actually made them for a Super Bowl party this year, in the 2 team’s colors.

  25. Your eating habits tickle my fancy. For years, when I hated vegetables, I ate them separate from the rest of the meal. They weren’t on the same plate. They weren’t even on the table at the same time. I ate them first, got them out of the way, then went to my “true meal.” And only then could I relax and enjoy my meal. This is true story. My friends used to make fun of me for it.

  26. now you’ve done it. first the damn rainbow cookies and now my second favorite the black & white. UGH i LOVE LOVE LOVE the vanilla side. i could never have the black side again in my life and i would be so fine with it but i lovee a great lemon cookie underneathe with the perfect vanilla and hard-ish type frosting. yum and double yum.

  27. I’ve never in my life craved a black and white cookie (I know it’s because I’m not a New York-er!) But throw some red velvet in there and it’s like a whole new red, black and white world! One I want to be a part of.

  28. I love Vanilla more than Chocolaty too , though i loveee chocolate , as a chocolate:-)
    But despite that i am enjoying a intensely dark chocolate baked delite right now with coffee as a mid morn snack 🙂
    Ur red velvet cookies remind me how muc i m missing my red velvet wp and i must get a dose soon.
    I baked red and white cookies jus once , actually i made them green and red for Christmas:-)
    But the cookie was too cakkey for me 🙂

    These seem perfect , delicious and beautifully glazed!
    Saturdays with Rachel Ray , that sounds good!

  29. I swear, some days i come here for the healthy eating and I am rewarded… Next day, it’s like you don’t even consider the size of my ass when you make a post.

    And I vote for a three way… some bites of vanilla only, some bites of chocolate only and some bites with equal amounts of each.

    B&W cookies are unheard of here in the heartland. But that and cheap Thai food is what i always have whenever I am able to get to NYC.

  30. Alisa is hilarious! I have had the real deal. Had to. Was in NYC and they were everywhere. Had them twice. The first time it was so not good, I thought – hmmm – must be the baker. I asked around. Went to “the best” bakery for the black and white – do you know it? I forget the name of it. Anyway, these are a cookie you have to grow up eating to love. Not so good. At least these days. Bland. The caky part is a surprise. But, really big. Easy to share. And, just – well, bland. So, your version looks YUMMY! Blasphemy – yes! Sacrilege – for sure! but, tasty – me thinks so!
    🙂
    valerie

  31. If you have issues, I must be having issues too, cuz I have very specific ways of eating my cookies as well, depending on the type of cookie… For instance, if there are chocolate chips in it, and any are sticking out, I’ll first make sure to “pull them out” and eat those, before I attack the rest of the cookie…

    Anyway, your cookies look delicious and devilish 😛

  32. Super yum!! Im totally with you girl..Its vanilla for me all the way! I do love a good chocolate but it doesnt stand a chance against anything vanilla. These cookies are the best of both worlds..and with red velvet as well. Awesome!!

  33. You bake as good as I barbecue.

    I suspect the inverse is true as well. I probably bake as good as you barbecue 😉 =)

    Love these little yin yang cookies, they remind me of the Town and Country surf gear we used to wear back in the 80’s when surfing. Damn I’m old.

  34. Amazing photos! The cookies came out perfectly. I have been meaning to make a red velvet something! I heard though that pecans are like the key red velvet ingredient – is that true? I think I read it on yahoo or something.. which isnt very trustworthy…

  35. Hmmm to me they look beautiful but just not enough chocolate! Maybe you and I should get together to eat these – I could eat the chocolate half and you could eat the white half. Though part of me thinks that reconciliation between white and black is a very good thing.

  36. I’m totally a vanilla person as well. I do the same thing… eat the chocolate first, just to get it over with, so I can move on to the vanilla.

    That’s not to say that I don’t like both sides… just prefer one over the other.

    These look great, by the way. Really, they’re beautiful.

  37. I’m sad to say that we forgot to get one of these when we visited NYC last year. What a shame! But now I have your recipe…with an even more delightful twist. Red Velvet! Thank you for sharing tonight! I hope you have a great Monday, my friend.

  38. These cookies are just amazing! I really must give them a go, though it will be a hard task to not cover the entire cookie in either chocolate OR vanilla glaze (it will be too hard to decide which half to eat first if they were both flavours!)

  39. For some reason, I have an almost overpowering urge to make Black and White Cookies – and swirl the 2 icings with reckless abandon, just so I can watch you eat them. Cruel, I know…..

  40. i’m sorry to say that i’ve never eaten a black and white cookie, but i feel a bond with them because of the seinfeld episode in which they were featured.
    ‘…the key to eating a black and white cookie is that you wanna get some black and some white in each bite. Nothing mixes better than vanilla and chocolate. And yet still somehow racial harmony eludes us. If people would only look to the cookie, all our problems would be solved.’
    look to the cookie, joanne. 🙂

  41. Do you know that I’ve never had a black and white cookie? Sounds crazy, right? This red velvet version definitely has me sold. I really got a good laugh reading about how you ate yours. I would probably have a similar method, no doubt. I think I’m partially OCD about stuff like that.

    These look delish, as Rachel would say.

  42. I face the same kind of dilemma with the sandwich cookies… what is best: bite into the whole thing or carefully separate each cookie, then lick the filling and eat the cookies? or eat one cookie, then the filling and finally the last cookie?
    As I have never tried the black and white cookies… I can see one more dilemma coming…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *