Peanut Butter and Jelly Bars

IMG_0707

My brother is not a seasonally appropriate person.  He isn’t aware of the fact that strawberries shouldn’t be eaten in January.  Or that beef stew actually tastes best when the temperatures are below 50.

Which may or may not be because he doesn’t like stew.

We are obviously barely from the same gene pool.

IMG_0678

Anyways.  As a result, he is often confused about what things should be eaten when.  Which occasionally makes for some awkward conversations when he requests things at completely inappropriate times.

Case in point.

Approximately two days before Christmas, the boy calls me and says, “I want peanut butter and jelly bars.”

He, apparently, had seen Ina Garten make them on the Food Network and got inspired.  (No surprise there.  Can anyone watch Ina and come away without even a hint of awestruck behavior?  Only the cold-blooded and pulseless.)

IMG_0708

At this point in my life, I was knee deep in rainbow cookie batter.  My fingers were stained all sorts of different colors.  And my kitchen had little pink, green, and white crumbs in every nook and cranny.

It was not the time for random requests.

So I was forced to inform him that PB&J bars were not holiday-appropriate and could he please pick something else to obsess over.  Perhaps something that in some way resembled a Christmas cookie?  Maybe? Please?

And that was the end of that.  Or so I thought.

IMG_0698

Approximately a month and a little bit later, I found myself poring over cookbooks trying to figure out what exactly to make for the Superbowl when the sugar coma still left over from Christmas finally lifted.  My thoughts suddenly felt very inordinately lucid.  And I remembered.

My brother was so excited that when I called him to tell him, the only reply he could muster was, “It’s about time.”

Ain’t he charming?

I’m not gonna lie.  Even though I made these bars “for him”, I found them to be one of the most amazing things that have come out of my kitchen.  I’m not even going to tell you how many I ate.  You would recoil in horror.

My advice?  Make them only when you know they are going to leave the house within about five minutes.  And don’t tell yourself it’s a good idea to keep a few at home for your “roommates” to eat.  You’ll only be lying to yourself.

IMG_0674

Peanut Butter and Jelly Bars
 
These are the peanut butter and jelly bars are the ULTIMATE throwback to your favorite childhood sandwich.
Yield: 24 bars
Ingredients
  • 2 sticks unsalted butter, room temperature
  • 1½ cups sugar
  • 1 tsp vanilla extract
  • 2 extra-large eggs, room temperature
  • 18 oz creamy peanut butter (I used Skippy Natural!)
  • 1½ cups AP flour
  • 1½ cups whole wheat flour
  • 1 tsp baking powder
  • 1½ tsp kosher salt
  • 18 oz raspberry jam
  • ⅔ cup salted peanuts
Instructions
  1. Preheat the oven to 350. Grease a 9×13-inch cake pan. Line it with parchment paper, then grease it again.
  2. In the bowl of an electric mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, cream the butter and sugar together on medium speed until light yellow, about 2 minutes. With the mixer on low, add the vanilla, eggs, and peanut butter and mix until all ingredients are combined.
  3. In a small bowl, sift together the flour, baking powder, and salt. With the mixer on low speed, slowly add the flour to the peanut butter mixture and mix until combined.
  4. Spread ⅔ of the dough into the prepared cake pan, making sure it covers the entire surface evenly. Spread the jam evenly over the dough. Drop small globs of the remaining dough evenly over the jam. Sprinkle with the peanuts. Bake for 45 minutes, until golden brown. Let cool and cut into squares.
Notes
Adapted from Ina Garten
Nutrition Information
Serving size: 1 bar

IMG_0688

You are reading this post on Eats Well With Others at https://joanne-eatswellwithothers.com. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to the author and or owner of Eats Well With Others. All rights reserved by Joanne Bruno.

Similar Posts

129 Comments

  1. ANYTHING BC makes is phenomenal!! Too bad I already bought the ingredients for s’mores bars to make for a volunteer event this weekend– these would have done the trick! Oh well, now I can make them and keep them all to myself 🙂

  2. Looks really awesome. First time I’ve heard of this treat. PB and jam on toast is great, this takes it to another level. And I noticed that the photo has two slices and some crumbs. Maybe its a clue of what was left.

  3. Ina Garten? or any of them for that matter – I guess I am cold blooded and pulseless…that said these look good but anything peanut butter is low on my favorite list unless its peanut butter, honey and banana…

  4. I have never liked pb&j until i made some bars like this for my son. I used half pb and half nutella and he loved it. Now i am hooked too! Yours look delicious and so glad my son can’t see this computer screen because he would be saying pooobeee which means make this now mommy!
    XO
    Jessica

  5. Oh my gosh, that looks SO decadent! You can thank Ina for that! What a perfect treat for a Superbowl party, though! 🙂

    Your brother is lucky you eventually cater to his odd requests!! 🙂

  6. I’m guilty. If I can find it in a store I’l buy it – in or out of season. Strawberries, I’ve been buying all year long. We just love them too much in our morning shakes. I suppose I might get more flavor from the frozen ones but they just don’t look as appealing.

    Great recipe! Can’t go wrong with PB & J in any form.

  7. I am the same with my brother. Totally the opposite in everything. I sometimes wonder how we both came up from the same uterus. I would make these bars to send them to my son’s school, otherwise I would eat them in a minute!

  8. I have yet to come across an Ina recipe I din’t like…she’s such a kitchen goddess, isn’t she? 😉 These look seriously amazing, Joanne! In fact, the only reason I’m not going to blow off work and make them RIGHT NOW is because I’m seriously scared I would eat the whole pan, lol!

  9. I LOVE these bars! LOVE THEM! I made them right before Christmas (after Velva posted them) and took them up to Ohio with me. Everyone raved about them. They were pretty much inhaled. I have to agree with you when you say that they are probably one of the best things to come out of your kitchen. I think they were also one of the best things to come out of mine as well. Keeper recipe for sure!

  10. Your brother must be a saint. I dont cook things for my family anymore. They think since I’m a chef, I can whip up anything like magic so I always disappoint them and bring a bottle of wine when I see them!
    And I use the EXACT same pb as you! I hate stirring pb! its like pb juice gets all over your clothes and underneath your fingernails and you smell like a four year old of weeks!

  11. Sounds about like my brothers. goobs. 😉
    This is a seriously dangerous recipe your throwing out there Joanne! Yeeesh, I don’t even like peanut butter but these look so yummy I have to make them in a big way!

  12. Brothers are dreadful like that. 🙂 I have three of them! I am so excited about these bars, Joanne. 🙂 Pure comfort and happiness and childhood memories all wrapped up in one. I need to make these soon. 🙂

  13. these are just beautiful! i remember making these a few years ago, but tried to “healthify” them by using fake sugar. huge mistake. some things are just meant to be made with the good stuff!

  14. Whenever I don’t cook dinner my hubby makes peanut butter and jelly sandwiches. Actually he makes it for dessert and breakfast too sometimes. Now why the heck I can’t do that and be so lean? SIGH. I know he would die and go to heaven with these so I might have to try my hand.

  15. One of my favorite sandwiches turned into a bar – How good is that? Sorry, couldn’t resist. My dad loves pbj, and since his appetite is kaput, I may bake these for him over the weekend.

  16. YUMMMMM!!!!! These look so amazing! Once I get my new kitchen in working order, these are at the top of my list. Anything with peanut butter needs to be stuffed into my face immediately!

  17. These look so good! I understand your frustration with your brother’s unseasonal cravings but I think this is the kind of thing you should eat all year round! And I love that you used raspberry jam… Sounds super delicious and can’t wait to try these!

  18. HA ha , i wish , i really wish my dear bro had cookie and cake requests , he does , of lemon bars and a few more , but not muc of a sweet eater!
    That said , aint ur bro happy to be featured here. Again.
    And wait , i thought when u were baking the Italian cookies , he was ”helping” u around ur place …and u were clanking pots and pans or should i say baking trays to get his attention,lol!
    I remember , he came over to ”help” and couldn wait for them to set 🙂

    Ok that said , i still havent got the italian cookie outa my mind and now i cant get this one outa my mind!
    Was trying to fit the Italian C in feb and hope i do:-)
    Absolutely fantastic!

  19. This is my kind of dessert! I’m thinking the fact they contain some whole wheat flour cancels out the 2 sticks of butter, right? Okay, maybe not. Perhaps I better have a way to share most of these before I make them and am tempted to eat the entire batch myself.

  20. Umm yeah, PB&J is good any time of the year for me! I wouldn’t be able to share, so I would probably have to cut the ratios down a bit for this one! Oh hell, I’m not gonna lie, I’ll make it as is and not feel guilty about how many I eat! =)

  21. Sweet, salty – salty, sweet. I don’t even know what to think here. These PB & Jelly bars are complete perfection!! Yes indeed. 2/3 cup of salted peanuts in there – you are killing me & I love every second of it!! xo

  22. Well darn. I was going to make them for company next week. But they’d be in the house and I’m still dieting.
    Love Ina. These looked great when I saw her make them and even better now. I would almost kill for one. (Is it because I’m starving for a sweet??)

  23. These are such viabrant little treats! They look delicious! My mother would love these because everyweekend she says “It’s peanut butter day!!” and has a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. This is because she is a teacher and can’t have peanuts during the week due to childrens medical needs. I’ll have to make these for her, thanks for the recipe!

  24. I grew up in a household where we couldn’t have peanut butter because my sister’s allergic. I’ve had a really tough time growing to love the peanut butter/jelly combo, but I definitely understand the appeal.

    These bars sound like something I could totally get into.

  25. I think I’m like your brother. I crave ice cream when it’s below zero and crave chili when it’s 90 degrees outside. I think it’s a sickness.

    Anyway, these look great. And I absolutely hate peanut butter & jelly.

  26. Lookin good lady! So, I haven’t ran outside for like two weeks. It is bitterly cold here and I HAVE to get motivated to get out there again. Any tips?
    Also, thanks for the sweet posts!

  27. I think you just knocked me off my chair. Seriously, those bars look AMAZING. And I _really_ mean it. Your brother is so lucky to have a sister baking such amazing treats. Now I just have to figure out how _not_ to run down to the grocery store (in the 10min before it closes) and get all those ingredients for a late night baking (and overeating) session…

  28. Yes. These look DELICIOUS. I adore PB and J though…I could eat one every day of the week and be happy. You are such a sweetheart, and I know any sibling would feel lucky to be in the same family as you! Thanks for sharing. I hope you have a wonderful Sunday. Rest, rejuvenate and spread some love!

  29. Holy moly! It’s funny – I just responded to your comment on my truffles with “the best way to not eat them all is to give them away” and that’s exactly your advice with these equally addictive treats. They look amazing!

  30. I love Ina. 🙂 My little brother would love these as well, except I’d have to make them with grape jam. Nothing else I’m afraid, according to him, will do with peanut butter. Brothers are like that, aren’t they? They look fabulous. 🙂

  31. This is one of my longtime favorite recipes, but I prefer to use seedless raspberry jam. I recently made a batch as a token of thanks for the plow guys. They loved them!

  32. Joanne, these bars look delightful!
    Your story reminds me of my own two kids! My son is always requesting something different.
    Adorable post. This recipe is definately a keeper. My daughter and I just love Ina Garten.
    Blessings,
    Catherine

  33. As soon as I saw this post, I began to swoon. I made Ina’s peanut butter and jelly bars during the holidays. They remain one of my favorites. They are absolutely delicious.

    Cheers.
    Velva

  34. MUST make these! If they had grape jelly, I could pass, but I always make my pb & j sandwiches with raspberry jam. Love the combo. It must be okay to eat these in place of a sandwich, right? They’ve got basically the same ingredients. 🙂 Also, love your pictures!

  35. these are always appropriate as far as i’m concerned. what’s not always appropriate, however, is breaking out with that stupid ‘peanut butter jelly time’ song in the middle of a crowded place. sometimes i do that–it’s a powerful force. 🙂

  36. Hmmm… bet your “roommates” loved all those bars you saved for them. 😉 I’m just imagining how good this’ll be with apricot jam (not a big berry jam fan… I know, I know) – YUM!

  37. I LOVE that recipe. I’ve made it countless times and people always go crazy for them. I agree about Ina. I watch her and think everything she makes looks delicious even the meat. Kind of.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *