Chicken Tikka Masala – Cook the Books

You know that feeling that you get when you walk into a really good, old-fashioned candy store. And the wall is decked with remnants of your past?

Those candy buttons.

The little wax bottles filled with that eerily neon-colored liquid.

Pop rocks.


There’s this feeling of elation and relief at being thrown back to what was, if memory serves you right, a simpler time. Remember when your biggest worry was who was going to be “it” in your neighborhood game of tag? Those were the days.

And also. Hope. Because hey. The stuff that made the “good ol’ days” so. Well. Good. Can still be procured! Maybe this new generation stands a chance after all! I mean, if they can appreciate the beauty of root beer barrels and Mary Janes, then all can’t be lost. Right?

Of course. There is also nostalgia. And a touch of sadness. Because this is not really present day, status quo kind of stuff. This is a blast from the past time warp. And you have this sinking feeling that it can’t last forever. No. You are dreaming. You will wake up (next to a pile of candy wrappers. And with a mild case of indigestion.) and have to go back to a life filled the modern-day confections that. Honestly. Kind of pale in comparison.
I think that this is how Nigel Slater felt while writing Eating For England, the book we are reading this month for Cook the Books. In it, Slater revisits dishes from England’s past. From his memory. From his childhood. He comments on how things were and how things have changed.

He describes at least twelve different types of biscuits. (Bourbons being, apparently, the best.)

Really. I’ve never seen someone get so worked up over biscuits.

In all, I would say that the book is a celebration of the English culinary history. The good. The bad. The ugly.

Which begs the question. Chicken tikka masala? Really?

Um. Yeah. Really.

Chicken tikka masala is actually the national dish of England. (According to Robin Cook, a former British Foreign Secretary). It is the number one dish ordered at restaurants there. And, to be fair, I understand why. It is Indian food for people who “don’t like Indian food” (Mom? Dad? You reading this?). It is creamy. Spicy. Delicious. Globalized fusion food heaven.

How would Slater feel about this? I daresay he’d be pretty irritated at me. (What about Yorkshire puddings, he would say! Or treacle tarts! Couldn’t you make one of those!)

Well. Like I said before. We can’t hold onto the past forever. Especially not when the future tastes this good.
Chicken Tikka Masala
Serves 4, adapted from Meeta over at What’s For Lunch, Honey?

Marinade
1 1/2 lb chicken thighs
1 cup plain yogurt
1 tbsp fresh ginger, minced
2 tsp ground cumin
1 tsp ground cinnamon
2 tsp chili powder
2 tsp freshly ground black pepper
salt

Tomato Gravy
1 14 oz. can diced tomatoes
3/4 cup almond milk
1/4 cup half and half
2 cloves garlic
1 dried chili de arbol
2 tsp cumin
2 tsp paprika
1 tsp butter
cilantro
salt and pepper

Mix all of the ingredients for the marination in a large bowl. Thoroughly mix until the chicken is nicely coated. Cover and refrigerate overnight.

On the next day, heat your broiler to high. Place the chicken on a foil-lined baking sheet and broil for 10-15 minutes.

To prepare the gravy, heat a large skillet to medium and melt the butter (or ghee if you have it). Sauté the garlic and chopped chili until fragrant. Sprinkle the ground cumin, paprika powder and a pinch of salt. Sauté for a further minute or two until the mixture turns into a paste-like texture.

Pour in the canned tomatoes, scraping the bottom of the skillet to deglaze it and to release any bits stuck to the pan. Simmer uncovered for approx. 10-15 minutes on low heat until the sauces begins to thicken, then add the grilled chicken pieces and cream/milk. Simmer for a further 10 minutes, thickening the sauce further and to heat the chicken and cream through.

Serve sprinkled with fresh chopped cilantro and cardamom-infused rice.

This is my submission to Cook The Books!

You are reading this post on Eats Well With Others at https://joanne-eatswellwithothers.com. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to the author and or owner of Eats Well With Others. All rights reserved by Joanne Bruno.

Similar Posts

81 Comments

  1. I am SO with you on this Joanne! I made traditonal British food for my post, but I couldn’t help feeling it was kinda….well….boring. I’d take a good Tikka Masala any day over the Treacle Tart I made. Looks yummy!

  2. Pop Rocks! Oh man, there’s a trip down memory lane. Actually, when I was in…maybe the 6th grade…my girlfriend and I would walk (for what seemed like a million years, but was actually only 20 minutes) to this little candy shop down the road from our houses. Wall to wall candy. It was a dream for a kid. I would save up my pennies and buy as many lemon drops as my pockets would hold. Good times.

    Chicken Tikka Masala is an awesome dish. And you’re right, it’s perfect for people who really aren’t into Indian food (which would be my family, too.) Although it does have cumin, which is very Indian and my parents avoid like the plague.

  3. Joanne, this looks amazing. And it also looks like I have everything in my house except the chicken. And the dried chile. Which I’d have to leave out (4 year old in the house). I am definitely going to try making this. Maybe even this week. Before trying any new recipes from my new issue of Vegetarian Times. That’s how good this looks.

  4. national dish of england! omg i totally guessed it would be india! crazy….
    i love chicken masala; especially the spices! i can taste it already! love cumin and coriander.. fenugreek is really good too!
    oh and ur so right about the nostalgia of old candy stores. there’s one downtown and everytime i go in i blow 50$ worth of candy on family and friends.. and myself obviously! last time i was in there i found these little minty/licorice breath mint things my mom used to tell me about- she had them growing up but could never found them. the candy store actually had them so i suprised her- she almost cried hehe.

  5. Funny about the candy…I loved Pop Rocks with Coke..LOL. I guess I felt it made them pop even more. I am really surprised to hear this dish is so popular in England. I have heard of this but never tried. I have been wanting to try Indian food. This looks like the perfect way to start. Great pics! Thanks!

  6. I believe we are all going through a Tikka Masala phase. This dish is a lot in fashion lately. I have never tried it, but yours looks really good. I think I have to make it so as to be able to form an opinion.

  7. i really need to try this. i have seen it all over the place, and it looks so good, but i’ve never had it. i love the i learn something every time i read your blog!

  8. I get a headache just thinking about all the candy I ate as a child. I was into chocolate… not really a fan of pop rocks and pixie sticks.

    This looks like wonderful soul food. I may have to try a vegetarian version of this.

    And the plate that you served it in is stunning!

  9. Joanne, I love chicken tikka masala, as a matter of fact is one the dishes that we always order at the local Indian restaurant…yours sure look so yummie and the pictures as awesome 🙂

  10. i think kids are doomed these days haha. sad but true. they don’t know nuttin about kick the can and late night man hunt.

    they SHOULD know about your cooking skillz though 😉

  11. Yummy! Well I dare say it is numero uno in England; what would you rather have? this or boiled meat with peas and carrots?
    I want to make this Joanne and I think I can I have got all that I need here.

  12. That’s so interesting that Chicken Tikka Masala is the national dish of England! I’ve actually eaten it there, and I have to say it was definitely the best I’ve ever had. Love this recipe — especially the marinade!

  13. You gave me such a warm happy feeling with your talk of old-fashioned, beloved candies. 🙂 And I LOVE the English dishes and think I seriously need to make biscuits one of these days. The chicken tikka looks so so good!!

  14. Chicken tikka is an Indian dish – which is basically spicy grilled chicken. The legend is that a Britisher walked into a restaurant & orderedChicken tikka, and when grilled chicken was placed before him, he asked where was the sauce. The chef added tomato sauce brought it back to the table and Chicken tikka masala was born 🙂

  15. The words “tomato gravy” sound so delicious, don’t they? This is one tasty looking meal Joanne. I’ve been wanting to make Chicken TIki Masala for awhile now and this is a big push in that direction. Great choice for Cook the Books.

  16. I love those retro candies too! I think the younger generation is hopeless unfortunately ;). I have heard that chicken tikka masala is England’s national dish! Apparently it was created in Indian from British colonials in India who thought the Indian food was too spicy and so they created something that was more palatable to British people. That’s what I’ve heard anyway, not sure about the truth behind that. This looks so delicious! When I need to make Indian food I’ll definitely have to try this.

  17. You know Joanne, a chef in Scotland tried to patent/get GI for chicken tikka masala as being a Scottish dish and we Indians were all suitably outraged! 😀

    I read a report a few months ago that Chinese food beat Indian and Thai to become the current British national favourite!

  18. Fun post and a great pick for Eating for England. Slater certainly loves his indulgent comfort food, candy and childhood favorites. 😉 I love chicken tikka masala and England has some of the best Indian food.

  19. The best Indian food I ever had was in the British Isles, so why not make Tikka Masala their national dish! Looks like a wonderful dish…accessible for the non-traveler, home bound homemaker. Thanks, Joanne.

  20. Hmmm. I find it hard to believe that Chicken tikka masala is the national dish in GB. How about fool? Or trifle? Or Yorkshire pudding? I think perhaps he meant in restaurants only. I bet when at home, Chicken tikka masala is not on the menu with any regularity.
    But it sure looks good. If someone wants to make it for me, I’ll try it! 🙂

  21. Huh. Indian food for people who don’t like indian food. I maintain a fairly consistent stance on the fence between liking it and not liking it. I guess I’ll have to try this. Oh darn. How sad.

  22. The national dish of England? I would think Shepherd’s pie or bangers and mash…I’ve only had this a few times before and loved it. Never made it at home. Sure looks delicious! I wonder if I can pass this off on my parents!?

  23. I never would have thought of this as an English food, but I guess it makes sense. Surprising to hear that it is the most frequently ordered food in British restaurants! Random.

    I want to state, for the record, that I liked, no loved, Indian food before it was popular. Like, twelve years ago. I was a crazy little eight year old begging for “ethnic gourmet” frozen dinners and to be taken to Indian places for treats. My favorite dish is palak paneer. Yum.

  24. CTM. yes yes yes!
    my fiance is an indian food fiend and awhile ago we went into a bit of a frenzy, trying to find the perfect recipe for chicken tikka masala — our go-to favorite order, because he “couldn’t stand depending on others for his indian food fix anymore.” alas, we haven’t been able to find a good recipe…can’t wait to give this one a shot!

  25. As always, I enjoy reading your musings. And your chicken looks delicious! I am sure it would win over your parents after the first bites. As for Slater’s love of biscuits, I can see how it is difficult to relate to it, since there is nothing like them in the US.

  26. Your chicken looks wonderful, and I thank you for setting me straight. Here I thought it was an Indian dish. Silly me! LOL! Matters not, you make it look fabulous, and sound wonderful enough for me to sit down to. That’s good enough!

  27. You clever little contemplative. And yes, Chicken Tikka Masala is England today. I hear it referred to in contemporary fiction all the time. In the Inspector Lindsay novels, isn’t it one of Barb’s favorites? Now I’m encouraged to try it myself, for the very first time, as it sounds so good.

  28. Yum!! You know…I like getting nostalgic (sp?) about those good old days whenI would search the wall of candy and only have to spend nickels or dimes…ahhhhh. Chick-o-sticks were my fave 😉

  29. So hearty and tempting – this recipe looks delicious. I think you’re right about the presentation; it looks amazingly hearty! Seems like this might be just the recipe to help me get over my own Chicken Tikka Masala. Thanks for sharing us your terrific post.:)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *